Updated
Spencer Pay Lake
Fishing pond · Spencer, Indiana
Spencer Pay Lake is a 3.5 acre lake nestled in a beautiful, peaceful hay field just north of Spencer, IN. Stocked mostly with channel catfish, where you can also fish for bluegill, crappie, and more. $30 per adult (11 yrs & up) for a 12 hour fishing pass. Open 24/7 during the season. Children ten and under are free with purchase of an adult fishing pass. MONDAY SPECIAL: $20 pass for Senior citizens & Veterans every Monday! Come enjoy the outdoors & catch some fish!
Things to Do Near Spencer Pay Lake
Top-rated tours and experiences around Spencer, powered by Viator — free cancellation on most.
Bear Lake Scenic Paddle
Private Kolkata Tour: Half & Full Day Options
Kolkata Hotels to Kolkata Airport drop: Private Transfers
Old-Growth Tree Climbing at Silver Falls State Park
We earn a commission on bookings — at no extra cost to you. Helps keep this site free.
Stay near Spencer Pay Lake
Find hotels near Spencer Pay Lake
Compare prices on Expedia — free cancellation on most rooms.
We earn a commission on bookings — at no extra cost to you. Helps keep this site free.
Weather at Spencer Pay Lake
Sponsored gear checklist
Pack smarter for Spencer Pay Lake
Useful gear categories for this kind of water spot. These links open Amazon search results so you can compare current options.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Frequently asked questions
- Where is Spencer Pay Lake?
- Spencer Pay Lake is a fishing pond in Spencer, Indiana.
- Can you swim at Spencer Pay Lake?
- There is no fixed answer for Spencer Pay Lake: whether it is safe to swim there on a given day depends on the water temperature, recent rainfall, and any advisories posted at Spencer Pay Lake in Spencer, Indiana. Check current water conditions before you go, and follow posted signs and local guidance.
- How is Spencer Pay Lake rated?
- Spencer Pay Lake in Spencer, Indiana has an average visitor rating of 3.9 out of 5, based on 59 reviews.
- What amenities does Spencer Pay Lake have?
- Visitor-listed amenities at Spencer Pay Lake include camping-nearby.
Visitor Reviews
Be the first to share your experience here
Join our community to share your water adventures
Earn badges as you share your experiences!
No reviews yet — share what you know
Been here? A quick note helps the next visitor plan their day. Handy things to mention:
Best Times to Visit
- ›Check for boat launch facilities and fees
- ›Obtain required fishing licenses before arrival
- ›Be aware of lake-specific regulations and restrictions
- ›Monitor water quality reports before swimming
Location & Contact
2144 US-231, Spencer, IN 47460
Spencer, Indiana 47460
Phone
+1 219-200-9164Popular Times
</> Embed this location on your site
Paste this snippet into your website to show a live badge for Spencer Pay Lake — free to use with the included credit link.