The Water Around Us

🎣

Best Fishing Spots in Indiana

1 top-rated fishing spots in Indiana. Discover prime fishing locations with excellent catches and beautiful scenery.

Spencer Pay Lake (Spencer, 3.9 from 59 reviews) is the most-reviewed of the fishing spots in Indiana.

FishingFly fishingShore fishingBoat fishingIce fishing

Top Fishing Spots in Indiana

Top 10 on the map

Locations approximate to pin

Spencer Pay Lake

Spencer Pay Lake

Fishing pond · Spencer, Indiana

Spencer Pay Lake is a 3.5 acre lake nestled in a beautiful, peaceful hay field just north of Spencer, IN. Stocked mostly with channel catfish, where you can also fish for bluegill, crappie, and more. $30 per adult (11 yrs & up) for a 12 hour fishing pass. Open 24/7 during the season. Children ten and under are free with purchase of an adult fishing pass. MONDAY SPECIAL: $20 pass for Senior citizens & Veterans every Monday! Come enjoy the outdoors & catch some fish!

Trip packing checklist

Gear for Fishing Spots in Indiana

Useful gear categories for this kind of water trip. These links open Amazon search results so you can compare current options before you go.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Rod and Reel Combo

Good entry point if you want one simple setup for the trip.

Compare on Amazon →

Tackle Organizer

Keeps hooks, lures, and small tools easy to find near water.

Compare on Amazon →

Polarized Sunglasses

Cuts glare so it is easier to read the water.

Compare on Amazon →

Rubber Landing Net

Helpful for landing fish while reducing line tangles.

Compare on Amazon →

Tips for Fishing Spots in Indiana

💡

Obtain necessary fishing licenses and permits

💡

Check local regulations on catch limits and seasons

💡

Bring appropriate gear for the target species

💡

Practice catch and release for conservation

More water adventures in Indiana

Rivers & Streams

Swimming Beaches

Dog-Friendly Beaches

Looking for more options?

Search every water location in Indiana or pick another state.

All water locations in Indiana Best fishing spots nationwide